Sunday, 8 August 2021

THEATRE-GOING WHEN YOUNG – PART 6 of 8





       31. The Boy Friend

 

The Boy Friend is frequently revived by amateur groups, because it is easy to stage, has a small cast, and is not too taxing on young performers.  It is delightful, too.  

 

Launching in the West End in 1953 it arrived a little after the era of the great Rogers and Hammerstein productions that so defined the musical theatre of the time.  It was neither pretentious nor high-tech, but its winning charm led to an opening season of over 2000 performances - one of the longest first runs of all time.  And then on Broadway for near on 500 performances.

 

The story, the lyrics, and the music are all by Sandy Wilson.  The "best" musical numbers (in my view) are The Boy Friend, I Could Be Happy With You, and It's Never Too Late to Fall in Love.  

 

With a somewhat modified plot, M-G-M and director Ken Russell brought The Boy Friend to the screen in 1971, winning two Golden Globe awards for newcomer Twiggy.

 

The season at Her Majesty's began on 31 March 1956: and the programme invites us to “Meet me at Scott's for Supper” – a forlorn last supper, perhaps? given that Scott's Hotel of 444 Collins Street, telephone MY1901, was gone by 1962; one of Melbourne's finest hotels, with renowned table and cellar, with a history of 109 years, with a galaxy of previous guests, and the longest continuously licensed hotel in Victoria, demolished by Royal Insurance for offices. 

 

    32. Nina

 

To think of Edward Everett Horton as little more than the Hollywood character actor of the '30s is to think too narrowly.  Horton had an acting career of nearly 70 years, which speaks of longevity, both genetic and thespian.  He was singing, dancing and acting in vaudeville from 1906 (at age 20), and in movies from 1922 - not yet talkies; but, until the talkies arrived, providing much practice for the funny faces and double takes of later years.  He made more than a hundred movies.  The programme describes him as  “America’s most beloved comedian”, but even for a theatre programme that's a big stretch.  At the time he was lively enough, and well able to put over the stage "business", but he was then 76 and nearing the close of his career.......although he did live for another eight years and for another half-dozen films.

 

   Nina had its origins in the French-language play of the same name by Andre Roussin, and arrived at the Tivoli, in the translation by Samuel Taylor, for a season commencing 30 April, 1962.  Taylor had success as the playwright of Sabrina Fair and The Pleasure of His Company, and wrote a number of film scripts.  His obituary (he died in 2000, aged 87) describes him as an American playwright in the tradition of Philip Barry, and Kaufman and Hart, and alludes to the time, through to the late 1960s, "when witty well-made drawing-room comedies about rich people were a staple of both Broadway and the West End".  Not surprising, then, that Taylor chose to translate and present a play fitting this profile.

 

But I doubt that Nina would be staged today - it has not worn well. And I doubt it was up to much in 1962, although no overall impression has stayed with me. Indeed, if the following synopsis of the opening scene is an indication, then Nina was of less substance than either froth or bubble:

Shortly after the curtain goes up Nina's husband confronts Nina's lover with a revolver. He comes to do his duty as the protector of the social order. But he has, unfortunately, taken a bad cold, and finds he must hand over the gun to the lover while he fetches the necessary medication from his pockets.

 

A concluding bit of trivia. In 1925 Horton bought a property in the Encino district (later suburb) of Los Angeles, a bit less than 20 miles from the city centre.  He lived there for the remaining 45 years of his life.  "Belleigh Acres" accommodated separate residences for his brother and his sister, and their respective families.  Unfortunately for Horton, part of the estate was compulsorily acquired in the 1950s for construction of a freeway.

 

       33.  Summer of the Seventeenth Doll

 

 Summer of the Seventeenth Doll was such a monumental success that it was staged all over the globe, and has been reprised many times. It premiered at Melbourne University's Union Theatre on 28 November, 1955, then had a Sydney season in January 1956.   Then a thirteen-week tour of country regions; followed, in 1957, by a regional tour of the U.K. culminating in the West End; and Broadway in 1958.  Plus film and television adaptations.  The programme is for the production I saw, I think, in January 1959.  It was at the Comedy Theatre. 

 

Wikipedia's generous introduction: "The play is considered to be the most significant in Australian theatre history, and a 'turning point', openly and authentically portraying distinctly Australian life and characters.  It was one of the first truly naturalistic 'Australian' theatre productions." 

 

The original cast had the author, Ray Lawler, playing Barney and Noel Ferrier playing Roo - the comic Ferrier later to be the host of a television late night variety/talk show, and a significant star in the Australian entertainment firmament.  The 1959 United Artists film significantly bastardised the story: it had John Mills as Barney and Ernest Borgnine as Roo (also Anne Baxter and Angela Lansbury), thus significantly "Americanising" its "Australianness".  It switched the locale from Melbourne to Sydney, and substituted a "happy ending".  Not happy Jan!  

 

The play, set in 1953, was the centrepiece of playwright, Ray Lawler's, career.  He later wrote two prequels, Kid Stakes (set in 1937) and Other Times (set in 1945), and the three plays together are colloquially known as The Doll Trilogy, and have been staged as a set. 

 

Barney and Roo are Queensland sugarcane cutters who for sixteen years past have spent the five months lay-off season in Melbourne with their respective inamoratas, Nancy and Olive.  Each year Roo brings Olive a kewpie doll, this year the seventeenth.  But this year the relationships unravel - Nancy has married someone else, Pearl is brought in for Barney as a substitute for Nancy, the men are conscious of their tiredness and worrying about their ability to continue with their laborious working lives, and Roo - fatally - suggests to Olive that they should marry.  The established order is shattered.

 

       34. With Devilish Glee:  An Evening Wasted with Tom Lehrer

 

In these Pandemic times the subject of mortality has become rather more front and centre, and the need to finish off half-completed projects just a tad more pressing.  And with this little Piece, in particular, the realisation that Tom Lehrer is aged 93 and is still with us [as is Ray Lawler, at 100], means that it remains available to discuss him in the present tense.

 

Tom Lehrer was a mathematics academic: a Harvard graduate, who had taught at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and other institutes, closing out his academic career (in 2001) at the University of California, Santa Cruz.

 

Tom Lehrer was also a songwriter and performer of satirical songs, songs he himself had written.  He was a rare example of a performer for whom the spotlight was not a drug.  He occupied the spotlight's brilliant glare for near 20 years, from his debut/discovery circa 1953 to his effective retirement in 1972.  Artists are not prone to retire: regardless of whether the muse keeps inspiring at the highest level the creative juices generally keep flowing.  Rare exceptions are Rossini, who retired - after composing his 37th opera - to enjoy his riches at age 37, and lived near another 40 years; and Tom Lehrer, who has spent nearly 50 years in "retirement".  He has noted that in his 20-year public career he wrote 37 songs, and performed 109 shows - including, obviously, his Melbourne gig in 1960.  The venue was the Melbourne Town Hall.

 

Lehrer arrived, already with a huge following - huge, certainly, among the student population.  Lehrer's first album, the 1953 Songs by Tom Lehrer, was an inconsequential 10" LP - so inconsequential that it had whipped up sufficient storm to pack the Town Hall!  By that time Lehrer's second album, More of Tom Lehrer (1959 - 12" LP) had been released, so there was plenty in Lehrer's oeuvre familiar to the receptive audience.

 

Lehrer's shtick was satire, satire underpinned by his great skill as a wordsmith, and all overlaid by his skills with rhyme, melody and metre.  His songs are surpassingly clever, and his nasal tenor delivery (self-accompanied at the piano) permits of no cover artist........with the possible exception of this correspondent, who for years sustained his kids with renditions of Lehrer songs on long car journeys!

 

On a topical note:  last year Lehrer forwent his rights to copyright, and placed all his works in the public domain.  Cynics might say that this is a way of encouraging an audience from a younger generation, but it's an altruistic (and uncommon) step nonetheless.  The royalties would, otherwise, have kept accruing to his heirs for 70 years beyond his death. 

 

       35. The School for Scandal

 

The School for Scandal was written by Richard Brinsley Sheridan (1751 to 1816).  Sheridan, born in Dublin, was not particularly prolific - ten plays only - but writing for the stage was but one of his interests.  He had a career in British politics: in the House of Commons for 32 years, and sometime Treasurer of the Navy.  From 1776 he was a principal owner of The Theatre Royal.  On a downbeat note:  The Theatre Royal was destroyed by fire in 1809.  It was not insured.  The story goes that Sheridan was taking a glass of wine while watching the conflagration, and when challenged for his insensitivity, rejoined that surely a man might be allowed to take a glass of wine before his own fireside. Sheridan died in poverty, but they had the grace to bury him in the Poets' Corner of Westminster Abbey.

 

The School for Scandal is a seriously famous play; at least it was seriously famous when I saw it as one of the mainstays of the 1956 Drama Festival held at the National Theatre. It was first performed in 1777, and had thus had nearly 200 years either to sink without trace, or to remain in the repertoire.  The theatre-going public had chosen the latter.  As had the devisers of school curricula; the play was on the study list in my year 10 school year; and I suppose it tweaked enough interest for me to attend the stage performance a couple of years later. 

 

As to my study of the play, I remember nowt; and, as to the staging, I remember little....except for the performance of one Adrian Rawlins.  Rawlins and I were contemporaries, and schoolfellows in years 7 through 9.  He always marched to the beat of a different drum, and his fruity portrayal of Sir Benjamin Backbite was memorable, especially given that he was a mere 17 or 18 at the time.  Rawlins lived a Bohemian life, centred principally on the world of jazz.  And also the world of poetry, in which he was both a writer and a performance artist.  He had the distinction of being sculpted during his lifetime: his depiction is atop a pole at the corner of Brunswick and Argyle Streets, Fitzroy. He died of cancer in 2001.

 

Mention of the character, Sir Benjamin Backbite, prompts acknowledgement of Sheridan the writer, and his proclivity for aptronyms, names that are peculiarly suited to their owners.  Sir Benjamin Backbite is a gossip and a scandal-monger - as his name suggests. The names of other characters in the play - Lady Sneerwell, Joseph Surface, Mrs. Candour, Snake - invite speculation.

 

Reverting to my earlier comments, I query whether The School for Scandal - over 240 years from its first production, and some 65 years from my earliest exposure in 1956 - remains seriously famous.  One litmus test: is it much performed today?  I have not been able to answer my own question.  There are Wikipedia references to latter day productions, but no way of gauging the frequency worldwide.  For those wanting the smell of some contemporary greasepaint I recommend the website stf-theatre.org.uk [Shakespeare at the Tobacco Factory], specifically the publicity for their production of The School for Scandal, which ran from 9 April to 9 May, 2015.  This company is based in Bristol, and the report of their 2015 production is extensive, and is accompanied with copious Director's Notes about Sheridan and his times, and several thoughtful reviews of the STF production.

 

Gary Andrews

 

 

Saturday, 7 August 2021

BRITAIN IN PICTURES - NUMBER 8

# 67  English Inns by Thomas Burke

 

The first reaction to one possessing expertise on hostelries is, surely, that that one must be well acquainted with ale.  With author Thomas Burke I shall never know, but I do know that the author of this volume not only had a lifelong acquaintanceship with his subject matter, but also accumulated sufficient authority to pen several books on the subject.  In The Book of the Inn (1927) he aggregated 200 literary extracts relating to inns and the culture of the inn.   In The English Inn (1930) he tells of his experiences: "tales of good hospitality and generous meals, old songs and stories and disputes and comfortable beds and 'shovel-board' and darts, in a seemingly unending journey across the country".  In Will Someone Lead Me to a Pub? (1936) he suggests, in light-hearted vein, that the pub "is the only place where a man may meet and talk with strangers on level terms".  And in English Inns (1943) he offers a distillation of his lifetime gleanings.



But, think again if you think that "the inn" might have been a single-minded lifetime focus for the author.  Thomas Burke, who lived from 1886 to 1945, wrote four books of poetry, 28 other non-fiction books (including the aforesaid four about inns), and 16 books of fiction - including one of which, incidentally, contains the story The Chink and the Child, filmed in 1919 by D.W. Griffith as Broken Blossoms, starring Lillian Gish, Donald Crisp and Richard Barthelmess. 

 

Returning to our theme, though, what does a lifetime's exposure to inns produce?  In short, Burke's little book is an affectionate and delightful tribute.  There is no grand theme, no overarching structure, no "message", merely a survey from which I shall take away, and share, a few of Burke's thoughts.

 

*  The first English inn was born when the first English road was made.

 

*  The inn has always been an essential factor of English life, as familiar to English eyes as the church, the castle, and the cottage.

 

*  Not only did the inn afford shelter and entertainment to the traveller, it was a semi-official centre of town.  The England that we cannot find in the Town Hall we can find in the inn.

 

*  The inn was regularly used for official meetings, sometimes the Quarter Sessions, sometimes Council Meetings.

 

*  In the centuries before the railway, every man who travelled twenty miles from his home had need of the services of an inn and its amenities, and it was in the inn-keeper's interests to provide these in as good measure or better than those of the traveller's own house.  Mostly he did.

 

*  And this is why, today, the old inn is often the noblest building of its town.

 

*  By their lifelong aim to keep up with the times, old inns now afford examples of the architecture of many centuries.

 

*  In the early days nobody travelled for pleasure or for the delight of looking upon rural scenery,

 

*  In the first thirty years of the nineteenth century coach travel and post-chaise travel was at its peak.  The kitchen fire was never out; post-boys worked in relays through the twenty-four hours.

 

*  But just when the main-road inn was enjoying record business the bustle was stilled by the arrival of the railway.  The railway followed its own route.  Hundreds of inns were ruined, and disappeared.

 

*  In their place evolved the railway hotel; but such places had all the faults of the old inn and none of its graces, and never succeeded in winning the affections of their customers.

 

*  However the inns (the ones that had survived) emerged from their long sleep when the car and the cycle opened the roads again.  The inns saw boom time once more. 

 

Postscript:  For those with a tweaked interest let me recommend The Old Inns of England, by A.E. Richardson, published by Batsford in 1934, with numerous subsequent editions.  This volume has the added advantage of "A Selected List of Notable Inns" arranged alphabetically by county.  It also has a quirky Foreword by the famous architect, Sir Edward Lutyens [think the Cenotaph, London and the Australian National War Memorial, Villers-Bretonneaux].  While applauding the new roads and the burgeoning motorists who have brought new life to the old inns he bewails the new "olde worlde" creations that are disfiguring the landscape.  He also bewails, somewhat contemptuously, the continuing restrictions left over from the [First World] wartime Defence of the Realm Act:  "It is amazing, in these days, that .....work should be hindered and hampered  by Act of Parliament bearing the initials that can but justly relate to some dotty old woman, D.O.R.A.".                                              

 

#3  English Music by W.J. Turner

 

The promo on the flap of this volume asserts that: "The common fallacy that we are not a musical nation has persisted so long that we have almost come to believe it ourselves".  The flap note continues:  "We are indeed a nation not only of music-lovers but of music-makers"; and that Turner's book "shows how glorious is the heritage that the great English composers have left to us".   There's an element of "protesting too much" here. Why not let W.J. Turner dispel the fallacy of national unmusicality in the course of his treatise without implying, before we even open the book, that he is embarking on some sort of sisyphean undertaking, or some sort of apologia for the inferior English product?   The likely consequence of this introduction is that we shall - wittingly or otherwise - have our thoughts about English music directed towards inferiority.  Why set up unprovable propositions that the author's efforts will be judged against?

 


Walter James Redfern Turner (1889 - 1946), the author of English Music  (1942), wrote nearly 20 books on music, including biographies of Beethoven, Wagner, Berlioz and Mozart. In addition, he published some 16 volumes of poetry; and was the General Editor of the Britain in Pictures series.  He was born in Melbourne - where his father was organist at St. Paul's Cathedral - but lived and worked in London from age 18.   He was a significant figure in English literary circles. He was not musically trained which, as one writer quizzically put it, left him "unhampered by any excess of technical knowledge".

 

As a topic,  "English music" could be approached from several angles, but it is notable that Turner adopts a very broad-brush approach, not nearly so focussed on the "heritage of the great English composers" as the flap note would suggest. In his execution Turner gives us two principal chapters: one on the "development" of secular music, and one on the "development" of non-secular music.   There is an introductory chapter styled "Music in England", and there is a concluding chapter on "The Revival of Music".   That very title has a foreboding: surely what needs to be revived must already be dead or nearly so.  We'll come to this point soon enough.

 

Turner's opening chapter has some startling propositions, all directed towards confirming his assertion that whereas in the sixteenth century England was known as "Merrie England", through to the nineteenth century it was known (in Europe) as "The Land Without Music": so at least a couple of hundred years of sterility in the middle. This is clearly not the expectation to be drawn from the words of the dust jacket.   

 

Turner supports his assertion with the following chronology:

   * music died with the Civil War and Cromwell and the rise of Puritanism from 1642;

   *  the Restoration of Charles II, returning to England after years in exile and bringing with him a large number of foreigners, did little to revive the court and its connection with the people;

   *  the successive monarchs were indisputably "foreign", starting with William III from Orange, and George I from Hanover, right through the other Georges to Victoria;

   * furthermore, the Puritan movement flared up again through the extreme Protestant evangelical movement of John Wesley......and while "there was a fresh outburst of popular music in the form of hymns" there was "no corresponding development among the professional musicians, as the Court and society encouraged only foreign musicians";

   * moreover, the industrial revolution was of "such colossal proportions during the first half  of the nineteenth century" that it wasn't until the slow-down in England caused by the rise of German and American industry "that a renewed interest began to be taken in music by the upper classes and the educational authorities".

 

Pretty bold stuff, and is there some way to validate the proposition that England from say 1650 to say 1850 was a musically bleak place? 

 

In answering this question I shall focus on serious music (because I think that's what Turner's thesis was doing, too), and I shall seek help from The World of Music (editor: K.B. Sandved), a 2,239-page mega-volume from 1954 - not because it is likely to be more authoritative than any other source but because it contains useful composer timeline charts.  The composers I have noted had to be no younger than 20 years of age at 1650 and, at the other end of the range, alive at 1850 but at least aged 20.  According to Sandved the prominent British composers who fit these criteria are five in number:

 

         Henry Purcell (1659 - 1695)

         Thomas Arne (1710 - 1778)

         William Boyce (1711 - 1779)

         John Field (1782 - 1837) - Irish!

         Sir Henry Bishop (1787 - 1856).

 

French composers who fit the same criteria were 15 in number, Italian composers 17, and German composers 20.  It seems that Turner has a point: English serious music was more or less in recess for 200 years.  And it seems that the blurb on the dust jacket, referred to above, is somewhat overblown.

 

Turner's chapter on the development of English religious/non-secular music does little to fire the blood, and why should it?  And why should the music itself fire the blood?  It is mainly choral, mainly madrigals, music much of which to this day remains in manuscript only and is thus not generally accessible.  Turner makes no reference to the existence of English religious music in his own time or during the immediately-prior era.  Perhaps the landscape of English religious music expanded little after 1850, and confined itself to the Anglican hymnal - Hymns Ancient and Modern, published 1861. 

 

As to Turner's take on English secular music: although wide ranging it is, I think, lightweight.  That is to say, he devotes his extensive knowledge and talents to the backwater in preference to the mainstream.  But, in fairness, focussing on the gravy rather than the roast beef is a needs must response to the beef being thin on the plate.  This chapter deals at length with secular carols, folk songs, and sea shanties; and with the music that accompanied dramatic performances, evolving towards opera.  Here we have Henry Purcell (The Fairy-Queen and Dido and Aeneas) and Thomas Arne (some 90 stage works with music), and the ballad-opera written by John Gay, The Beggars' Opera.  As to enduring orchestral music: nothing to see here.

 

The potage thickens in Turner' final chapter, The Revival of [English] Music.  Coming off 200-odd barren years, hopefully there will be much to say about that revival.  Well, not so much.  Turner posits that "a genuine and inspired popular music can only come direct from the life of the people, and so far, the intense industrialisation of Great Britain in the twentieth century has proved unfavourable to the creation of any popular musical art " - remember, this was being said in 1942.  Turner, however, concedes that the rise of the music halls produced enormous quantities of music.  But cop this bit of spleen:  "This tendency (towards absence of sincere emotional expression) became much accentuated during the first quarter of the twentieth century.  The love song, as it has been known in the past, has entirely disappeared, and its place has been taken by a cheap imitation of the negroid sentimental ditties of America.  The total absence of sincerity and passion in the popular music of the twentieth century is a most striking phenomenon............".  His overall proposition was probably wrong, and he was certainly wrong-headed.  Some judicious editing would have been advisable.  

 

As to serious English music during the 100 years since 1850, Turner's observations are brief.  But he does mention Elgar, Delius, Vaughan Williams, Holst and Britten; and whether Turner recognised it or not,  the revival had indeed arrived.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  # 96 British Dogs by A. Croxton Smith

 

Not one of the great mysteries of the ages, I suppose, but how can a volume that has uncut pages, and thus has never been read, at the same time have lost its dust jacket?  I make this minor complaint simply because, without the front flap, I'm deprived of the ability to read the publisher's comments.  In the event, this is a handsome volume (in a series of invariably handsome volumes), and in pristine condition.  And, in any case, the internet has told me a lot.



Arthur Croxton Smith (1865 - 1952) was a prolific writer on canines, with a number of his books still in print today.  The internet is replete with opportunities to buy them.  As always, the editors of Britain in Pictures have selected an author who clearly knew his stuff.  

 

The nomenclature of Smith's chapters is itself a window into the story of the British dog, and invites us to enter and to follow.  This is not to be a breed by breed analysis, rather a journey through the history of the dog in Britain.

 

In the first chapter of British Dogs (1945), Dogs of the Dim Ages, Smith suggests that historically there were no dogs native to Britain.  Dog skeletons from the neolithic period were discovered at Avebury in Wiltshire in 1928, but these species of dog are thought to have died out.  All modern dog species - their ancestors, at least - are believed to have been brought from overseas.  Mastiffs were known in Britain at the arrival of Julius Caesar in 55 B.C.E. and, having originated in Assyria, may well have come with the Phoenicians in their quest for tin (which quest went back as far as 2000 B.C.E.).   Archaeological research from the Roman military settlement of Corbridge in the north of England (occupied from 80 to 120 A.D.) revealed skeletons of numerous dogs, including greyhounds and dachshunds, that presumably came with the invaders.

 

Smith next discusses a period of history when large areas of the countryside were set aside for the exclusive use of the monarch and the nobility.  In the chapter Under the Forest Laws we learn that such laws were first promulgated by King Canute in 1016, and that they were harsh and oppressive.    "Hunting in Forests is sport for Kings and Princes, and therefore not to be used by every common person........." And from a description of the situation still pertaining some 500 years later: "If a man started his hounds on game of any sort outside a forest, and the animal crossed the boundary, then the hounds had to be called off.......and , if they killed, their owner was regarded as a trespasser and made himself liable to penalties........".  

 

As further deterrence there was the maiming of mastiffs.  These dogs, the most formidable guard dogs, were widely kept about farmers' houses - provided they had been expediated in accordance with the laws of the forest.  The brutal custom of maiming by expediation was introduced by Henry II (1154 - 1189).  "Three claws of the fore feet shall be cut off.......by setting one of his fore feet on a piece of wood eight inches thick, and a foot square, and then setting a chisel of two inches broad upon the three claws of his fore foot, to strike them off at one blow........".  Interestingly, this mutilation was applied to mastiffs only, not to greyhounds, equally adept pursuers.        

 

In his next chapter, The Years Roll On, Smith takes us to more civilized times, although the "sport" of bull and bear baiting rates a mention.  But, so too, does the use in the mid-1800s of dogs to draw the small carts of hawkers, and for the deliveries of butchers, bakers and the like.  He spends some time detailing the earliest references to various breeds.

 

The chapter, Dogs at Work, allows Smith to expound the attributes and uses of various breeds of spaniel, setter, retriever, and pointer - the gun dogs.  And we move straight on to the complementary breeds , Hounds that Hunt by Scent, Smith claiming that "any picture of the sporting life of Great Britain would be wholly incomplete without reference to the greatest of all sports - foxhunting". 

 

With this assertion I was fast losing interest in Smith and his opinions, and I swiftly passed by his chapters on greyhounds, the terriers, and other sporting breeds.  Furthermore, I was happy to give The Little Ones the bum's rush, having a personal anathema to yappers and snappers; and my disdain lasted through The Non-Sporting Breeds (collies and Alsatians, for instance).

 

My new-found disdain faded a little with Smith's final chapter, A New Era in Dogs.  This is a summary of the advancements of the century previous to writing - advancements in the developments of dog breeds, the role of dog shows (the first in Britain dating from 1859), and the establishment of the Kennel Club in 1873 and its role in preserving the purity of breeds.   As of 1873 there were 40 breeds of dogs recognised, and categorised into Sporting and Non-Sporting sub-groups.  Some 70 years later, as at the time of Smith's publication, there were 95 breeds recognised by the Kennel Club, classified thus:  Sporting  (19), Gundogs (19), Terriers (20), Non-Sporting (25), and Toys (12).  And, as of today, the Kennel Club recognises 218 dog breeds. Whereas 2000 years ago there were no British breeds of dog, nowadays many breeds have been imported from the Continent and elsewhere, and nationalised.  I have not ascertained how many of the 218 breeds have been invented in Britain, but each of them that has, I daresay, is more freaky than the previous.

 

Postscript:  Croxton Smith's confident use of the word expediate got me searching for more detail. Several dictionaries drew a blank, as did a simple Google search for the word.  But I found the following description........on an English/Turkish Dictionary website no less!

 

To injure (a dog) by cutting away the pads of the forefeet, thereby preventing it from hunting.  The statute, which prohibited all but a few privileged individuals from keeping greyhounds or spaniels, provided that farmers and substantial freeholders dwelling within the forests might keep mastiffs for the defence of their houses within the same, provided such mastiffs be expediated according to the laws of the forest. This "expediating", "hambling" or "lawing", as it was indifferently termed, was intended to maim the dog so as to reduce to a minimum the chances of his chasing and seizing the deer, and the law enforced its being done..........in the manner described above.

 

# 71  British Photographers by Cecil Beaton

 

In an earlier one of these Britain in Pictures Pieces I mentioned Australian, Frank Hurley, who accompanied Mawson to Antarctica (1911 to 1914) as photographer, and then went with the 1914/1916 Shackleton expedition.   At one end of the scale, Hurley might be described as an action photographer; at the other end, Cecil Beaton's celebrity portraits captured the still life of a world away.   Hurley was undoubtedly a self-promoter, but would have been eclipsed by Beaton's Eddie Everywhere flair.  [Incidentally, their lives overlapped by 58 years - the years 1904 (Beaton's birth) to 1962 (Hurley's death) - but I have no knowledge of whether they ever met.]

 

My lens of fifty-plus years ago sees Cecil Beaton in the rather unfavourable light of a self-promoting showman, but reference to his biography reveals a lifetime of achievement way beyond the dress-ups in a picture hat.  We are breathlessly informed by Wikipedia that Beaton was bullied by Evelyn Waugh at his first school; and that at a later school his fellow students were overwhelmed by the beauty of his singing at school concerts!  These may or may not be clues to the later Cecil, but seek no further than his nanny with a camera, who taught him about photography and film processing.  

 

Once he was proficient he sent photographs to London society magazines. Following his first exhibition in London, he moved to New York and built a reputation there.   At one time he worked for both Vanity Fair and Vogue. He was a favoured portraitist for the Royal Family.  But enough tattle!  Except for the encompassing Wikipedia headnote: Fashion, portrait and war photographer; diarist; painter; interior designer; costume designer for theatre and film; and Oscar winner.  Clearly Beaton was a high achiever.

 

And despite all this, in British Photographers (1944) Beaton does not mention himself or any of his achievements (although the illustrations include three Beaton photographs).  So flamboyance, yet modesty.  Go figure!





Beaton's book is a leisurely panorama of and about photography, not confining itself strictly to British, and not much interested in the photographic process.  Beaton himself was not over-concerned with technology and the latest developments, and he spares us the dry minutia of his trade.  But he does detail and pay tribute to his photographer predecessors, numerous names that no longer prod a memory.  And he gives us some history, remembering that, at the time of writing, "photography" was barely a hundred years old; moreover, it hadn't yet encountered the digital world.

 

  With a brief pause to mention Da Vinci's manuscript describing the "camera obscura", and the later pin-hole realisation of the concept, and the later again efforts to "fix" the image, Beaton brings us to Henry Fox Talbot. Talbot spent years finding a way to attach camera obscura images permanently to paper; and he succeeded.  But his slow progress proved to be too slow: by 1835 he had created the negative,  and had found a way to affix positive images to paper, but it was the Frenchman, Daguerre, who in 1839 announced the discovery of photography.

 

Daguerre, too, had spent years in perfecting his photographic process, his breakthrough having come when he inadvertently placed a camera obscura plate in a cupboard overnight and found next morning that the image on the plate had been "developed".  There were vapours of mercury in the cupboard.  Eureka!  "We can count the paving stones, see the dampness produced by rain, read the name of a shop," said one observer.  Said a famous painter: "From to-day painting is dead."

 

When Talbot heard of Daguerre's discovery he hurriedly released details of his own research; and later in 1839 read a paper before the Royal Society.  The two processes were quite different - the Daguerre process produced one image only, the Talbot process produced a negative from which limitless photographs could be taken off.  This ease of reproduction, coupled with the small cost of such re-production, the rise of the middle class, and the increase in leisure time, ensured that photography "took off".  

 

The props provided by the emerging photographic studios facilitated theatrical poses, and the photographic art form was born; and, in time, ways were found to enhance the sitter's appearance by retouching - softening features and obscuring double chins.  This ironical turning back from the "reality" that the camera provided over painting was a practice that did not last.

 

The arrival of photography, Beaton observes, made the Victorian age more real than any previous period.  "Compared with the work of the writer, the efforts of the photographer may seem crude and superficial, but it is the camera that brings Gladstone and Disraeli, Thackeray, Dickens and Tennyson before our eyes complete down to the very smallest detail, their clothes, their expressions, the attitudes they affected."  "No less significant are pictures of the London streets, at a time when London low-life was still Dickensian."  

 

Beaton enumerates a number of British photographers and discusses each modus operandi and each contribution to the history and the development of photography.  Concerning both the private and the ephemeral nature of much of the photographic field, he references the (then) recent "Salvage Campaign" conducted by Country Life magazine.  The magazine ran a competition for the most interesting Victorian photographs found in family albums and old trunks.   Many treasures were unearthed.

 

And Beaton talks of the tribulations of outdoor photography.  Not until 1880 did factory-prepared plates and paper become available.  A fleck of dust or a fly might ruin the plate, only distilled water could be used, and there was a running battle with cumbersome apparatus.  And there was the risk of inhaling fumes of mercury.  A leading still life photographer, Roger Fenton, resolved to photograph the Crimean War - and took with him 36 large chests of photograph paraphernalia.  Later, Herbert G. Ponting went with Scott to the Antarctic - pre-dating photographer Frank Hurley's Antarctic trips with Mawson and Shackleton. "Ponting brought back extraordinarily beautiful photographs of icebergs, of the grottos in icebergs, of the Terra Nova in ice floes under the midnight sun, of penguins, and of dog teams resting under Daliesque formations of ice and snow."

 

Much of Beaton's book concerns the field of celebrity (and studio) photography, and the photographers practising in that genre.  His attitude towards the near past is somewhat tepid, but tempered by some more recent developments.  "There is no doubt that the 'candid camera' pictures, at first as great a shock to the beholders as to the sitter, have had a most refreshing influence and have opened studio windows to invigorating breezes."  And praise for innovation abroad: "The technical brilliance of the photographs in American magazines has helped to counteract our slipshod tendencies......We can now look at photographs caught in a hundred-thousandths of a second, aerial photographs taken many miles in the sky, and photographs taken without visible light."

 

Writing in 1944, Beaton included some topical observations. "To-day, the best photography comes from the front line.  The Germans, during their meticulously well-organised invasion of France and the Low Countries, had arranged that their victories would be given full propaganda value; and there resulted 'stills' that might have come from the studios of Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer.  In the first years of war, outstanding British photographs were as rare as British victories; but now the Army photographers have got into their stride, and some of their latest photographs of the war have the romantic quality of Delacroix paintings."

 

He concludes with a hope for the (post-war) future.  "Photography is a medium with enormous possibilities: we must endeavour to bring it into always closer and closer relationship with the problems of contemporary life.  It has its limitations, just as painting and sculpture have theirs.  But there are some textures, some visual impressions, some aesthetic moods, that no other means of representation yet discovered can render with such delicacy, such accuracy or such dramatic distinction."   

 

Beaton was clearly much more than an affected show pony.

 

Gary Andrews

 

 

 

 

 

Monday, 19 July 2021

AND NOW FOR SOMETHING COMPLETELY DIFFERENT: I OFFER MY CONDOLENCE

 

This Blog comprises letters of condolence, letters written by me over some 60 years - correspondence emanating from my office situation, and correspondence originating from home. I have been a bit reluctant to share these letters in a Piece, principally because of the somewhat weird nature of a collection of messages of condolence.  There is also the personal nature of the subject matter.  


Because of my awareness of the sensitivities I originally de-personalised the letters by reducing names to initials, but that seemed a bit precious.  None of the recipients is identified; and although a number of the late departed will be identifiable they are treated respectfully - and they have, after all, left the stage. 

 

- ooOoo -

 

The personal note, I believe, is a more heartfelt way to convey sympathy than the black-edged card with its sanctimonious sentiments; and it has been my lifelong habit to write letters of condolence to the family (usually the surviving spouse) of deceased friends, workmates, professional colleagues, and clients.

 

The late 19th Century produced a range of compendiums of useful knowledge, badged as “cyclopaedias”, or “self-instructors”, with sections devoted to disparate topics - from household hints to how to deliver a speech to simple maths to recipes to countries of the world to sample job application letters, and to everything in between. But I have never seen examples of condolence letters; and hence offer the following as templates for someone else to follow.  It is more likely, however, that they are simply the record of my lifetime of “choosing the right words”.

 

I am not reproducing the responses I received.  They were many, and they were invariably warm.

 

- ooOoo -

 

To a workmate on the death of his wife: 

 

May I extend my deepest sympathy on Wendy’s death. The circumstances seem to make it all the more tragic; and you will no doubt endure a period of shock, then realization, and eventually resignation.

 

I trust that things are made a little easier for you through the knowledge that there are many, like myself, who are sharing your grief.

 

 

To the widow of a family friend of my mother, and me:

 

I was distressed to hear tonight, from my mother, that Frank had died at the weekend – and doubly upset because I had intended to call in soon to see you both and to return Frank’s book, Isle of Mountains, which I’ve had for some time.  But, especially, I wanted to thank him for sending me his Folies Bergere program.  This is something I know he treasured for over fifty years, and be assured that I too shall treasure it.

 

But it was not to be.  Please accept my heartfelt sympathy; and if it’s any consolation do try not to dwell on Frank's death, but rather remember him – as I do – as the soul of affability and good humour.

 

 

To a workmate on the death of her husband:

 

I am very sorry to hear of your husband’s death, and extend my sincere sympathy.

 

A sudden death may be merciful, but it gives the family no opportunity to prepare for the event; and you must have suffered a great shock.

 

The pain will pass in time, but in the meantime I do hope that you have family and friends to provide comfort.

 

 

To a close client on the death of his mother:  

 

I was in your office the other day when the message came through that your mother was declining, and it was obvious that you were distressed at the news.  You must have been very close.   So I can imagine your anguish at arriving too late.

 

Mark, you have my sincere sympathy.  The fact that your mother was old and ailing makes her death no easier to accept, but I’m sure the loss can be more readily borne by pressing on with the normal routine, while occasionally pausing to reflect upon what a fine mother she was and upon your happy times together.

 

 

To a fellow accountant on the death of his wife:

 

I have just heard the tragic news about your wife and am writing straight away to offer my sincere sympathy.  You will be going through a harrowing time, but for your family’s sake you must be strong, and face the future with resolution.  It may help you to know that there are people like myself offering quiet encouragement.  Don’t hesitate to call on me if there’s any practical assistance I can give.

 

 

To a workmate on the death of her brother:

 

I was so sorry to hear of your brother’s death. What a tragedy! and all the more upsetting because it was so sudden and unexpected.  And your anguish must be heightened by being so far from home, and your family, when family would be such a comfort.

 

Let me know if there’s anything I can do to brighten your life through this troubled period; in the meantime, you have my heartfelt sympathy.

 

 

To the son of a company director with whom I’d had close dealings:

 

I was saddened to see of your father’s death, and I thought you might care to know how he touched upon my life during the ‘60s.

 

I was then a young clerk at the accountancy office of Hancock & Woodward, and one of my jobs was to prepare information for the Board of Australian General Investments Limited.  Mr. Buesst was a director of the company, and I had frequent contact with him over a number of years – many times visiting his Queen Street office to have cheques and documents signed.

 

The company, I think, was founded about 1928 and, if not a foundation director, Mr. Buesst was a director from its first or second year.  As I recall, he remained a director until the company was taken over (some years ago). He was a notable survivor, other directors – Sir Alexander Fitzgerald and Justin Hancock – having pre-deceased him.

 

I always found your father to be a kind and affable man, and this is the way I shall remember him.  I trust that his passing was comfortable, and extend my sincere sympathy.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:  

 

Jack's death occurred while I was overseas for an extended period and I did not catch up with the sad news until I received Trevor Brown’s message upon returning home.  I was sorry to hear of Jack’s passing and fondly remember our days together at Irish Young & Outhwaite.  Very much the end of an era.

 

Trevor tells me that the funeral service was well attended, and was a fine celebration of Jack's life.

 

I do trust that you have coped well with the initial period of mourning, and that things are gradually returning to normal.  All my best wishes.

 

 

To the widow of a fellow accountant:

 

I am writing to express to you and your family my sincerest condolence over Geoff’s death.  Although Geoff’s illness has been protracted and his death not unexpected, nevertheless the grief is just as profound.

 

Geoff and I have been Discussion Group associates over many years, but our connection goes back to the 1960s when he was with Offner Hadley; so we’ve known each other a long time.  He was my friend.

 

 

To a former workmate on the death of her husband:  

 

It’s a shame that “blasts from the past” so often blow in on unwelcome winds; and I’m sorry to be making contact after so many years against the backdrop of Frank’s death.

 

You have my sincerest condolence.

 

The reference in the death notice to “a long illness” means that you yourself must have endured a long period of anxiety and stress.  That’s over now; and I trust that, despite your grief, you will soon enter happier times.

 

The knowledge that old friends like me are thinking of you may be of some comfort.

 

 

To a friend on the death of her father:  

 

Stan’s death was expected for some time but, as you said on the day of his funeral, it still caused such a lot of grief.  He was clearly a man much loved.

 

Your mum’s re-location at this stage is fortuitous, I think.  The move will certainly pre-occupy her thoughts; and make it a little easier for her to get over the trauma of the last few weeks.  I certainly hope so.  And I hope that, for you, things return to normal pretty soon.

 

Anne joins with me in sending our sincere sympathy.

 

 

To the sister of a former client and friend:  

 

I was saddened to read the notice of Geoffrey’s death.  You may remember me as Geoffrey’s long-time accountant and friend.

 

Sadly, Geoffrey and I drifted apart in recent years. For some reason (unknown to me) he decided to have his affairs looked after elsewhere; and a change in my business activities meant that I was less frequently in the City and therefore not able to call so often at Raglan Street.  I did call from time to time, however, but there was no one there, and my business card slipped under the door produced no response.  And it was not until quite recently that B.B. told me that Geoffrey was in a nursing home.  So sad that such a vibrant and gregarious person should be removed from the company of his friends.

 

I know how much Geoffrey cared for you, and I do trust that you are able to bear up under your loss.

 

 

To a client on the death of her father:  

 

It was not until I spoke the other day to Danny that I learnt of your father’s death.  I am writing to offer my belated condolence.

 

I know that your father was no longer enjoying independent living and that his death was not unexpected, nevertheless there is always the shock and the grieving process.  I trust that things have not been too difficult for you and that your life has by now returned to normal.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:

 

I was sorry to learn of David’s death, but pleased to be able to attend Monday’s thanksgiving service at St. Michael’s.  I was very much impressed by the tributes, by Francis McNab’s conducting of the service, and by the overall simplicity.

 

Although I was David’s partner at Deloitte for a number of years, I did not “know him” as the person whose life was recounted for us. I am sure that I was the loser.

 

Best wishes to you and your family; and I trust that with the support of family and friends you will soon be able to settle back into something approaching normality.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate:  

 

I was pleased to be able to attend Friday’s gathering for Ray, and to hear the words and tributes.  I trust that you were able to “get through” the ceremony at Springvale; and that things are gradually returning to normal for you and the family.

 

Ray was a long-time workmate and friend, and it was sad to see him go so early, and with such suffering.

 

You have my sincere sympathy.

 

 

To a business associate on the death of her mother:

 

I was very sorry to hear the other day of your mother’s death.  I know that her illness has over recent months caused you great concern and stress and, in one sense, I guess her death was a relief.  But equally true it’s a great loss and cause for grief.

 

I do trust that the grieving process is not too prolonged, and that things will soon be back to normal for you.

 

My thoughts are with you at this difficult time.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:

 

Jack’s death was a great shock to us all, not least to you and your family, but I trust that things are gradually getting back to “normal” for you.  Things, of course, will never be the same; but the sorrow will abate………and you will always have your memories.

 

Jack was one of the best accountants I ever knew, certainly the “quickest” and the most intuitive.  And a good man and a good friend with it.  What more can I say – he will be greatly missed.

 

Gwenda if there is anything that I can do at a practical level – business affairs, tax return, Jack's private clients – don’t hesitate to let me know.  Byaduk is not so far away, and I’d be happy to spend a day sorting through matters if that would help.

 

 

To long-time acquaintances on the death of their son: 

 

From the eulogies it was clear that Rhett was a fine man. I didn’t know him; but I do know the two of you, and I share your grief.  The horror of losing your son must be crushing.

 

I hope that you are sustained by the knowledge that others are thinking of you in your sorrow.

 

Anne joins with me in sending condolences.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate:  

 

As you will know, I was recently contacted by your son, and was able to identify myself to assist with the proving of Geoff’s Will. What a “blast from the past”!

 

I was sorry to hear of Geoff’s death, but his living to such a fine age has left you with a lifetime of memories.  I do trust that Geoff’s final months and years weren’t too much of an ordeal for him, and not too stressful for you.  You have family, and that must be very consoling.

 

So much time has passed since Geoff and I worked together [from 1960].  After I left Hancocks in 1972 I spent some years at Irish Young & Outhwaite (later Deloitte), and concluded with a dozen years in private practice in Ringwood. I’m quite retired (age 73) but frustratingly busy; wife Annie of 43 years, and three adult children.

 

I trust that your time of grief quickly passes, aided perhaps by the knowledge that the thoughts of others are with you.

 

 

To the son of a former business partner:

 

I was thumbing through some old journals the other day and was sorry to see the report of your father’s death.  Although it is some years since I last saw him, I have fond memories of Roy calling in at the H & W office in Melbourne and at various national conferences.

 

I’ll no doubt be in Brisbane again one day and will make the opportunity to talk – as we did at last year’s Congress – of old times once more.

 

 

To the widow of a former client:

 

I knew “Jerry” over some years when I looked after his (and your) income tax affairs while working with Irish Young & Outhwaite. In later years I would occasionally see him around the neighbourhood, and we would reminisce about former times. Please accept my sincere condolence.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:

 

Let me add to the comments already made by John Moule and express my sincere sorrow at Bill’s passing.  He was one of those rare people for whom it is impossible to find anyone who has a bad word.  It was a great shame that indifferent health in his final years prevented Bill from leading the “good life” as he would have wished, but no doubt there were compensations in the family circle.

 

Don’t hesitate to contact me if you need assistance in business matters.

 

 

To the widow of a business partner:  

 

I have just returned from overseas, and am saddened to learn of Tony’s death.  I regret having missed the funeral and being able to express my condolences in person, but wanted you to know that Tony will be sadly missed.

 

I hope that by now things have somewhat settled down for you and the boys, and that you are coping with your grief.

 

 


To the widow of a business partner:

 

Well it was a good fight, and a tribute to you as well as to Gaven.  But the battle was lost, and we are all the poorer for it.

 

Right now nothing can relieve your loss and your anguish. But it may be some solace to know that others are feeling for you and the children in your grief.

 

Gaven was a man, and a man much loved and admired. It has been a privilege to know him.

 

 

To the widow of a former business associate:

 

I saw with sorrow the newspaper notices of Frank’s death, and I am writing to express my sincere condolence.  You will remember me from the heady days of the Abacus Investment Club; but my contact with Frank was much broader in that I was with Hancock & Woodward at the same time as his association with Silverton.  We saw a lot of each other in a business context. I wholeheartedly endorse the comment made in the death notice that he was one of nature’s gentlemen.

 

 

To the widow of a former partner of my accounting firm:

 

Although I attended Ewart’s funeral and have kept in touch – both before and since – through Phyl Lardner I am conscious of never having recorded my profound sorrow at Ewart’s passing.

 

We were, as you know, of a different generation and it was never my privilege to be Ewart’s partner, but his continued involvement with the affairs of clients of the office brought us into close contact over the past eleven years, and that contact was responsible for not only a good working relationship but a close friendship.  Please accept my deep sympathy.

 

I have no doubt that the many expressions of comfort have been of considerable help, but I also appreciate that time alone can heal. Do not hesitate to call on me if there is anything at all that I can do to help you in the time ahead.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:  

 

I have returned to the office after a couple of weeks’ break to hear the sad news of Ron’s death.  I extend my deepest sympathy.

 

Ron was one of the “identities” of the late Irish Young & Outhwaite firm, and could always be relied upon for a friendly word and a sound judgment.

 

Although we have not had the benefit of his counsel in recent times, nevertheless his passing leaves a significant gap.

 

 

To the family of a long-ago business associate:

 

I write to express my condolence at the death of Arnold Piesse.  Arnold and I were for some years associated in business, when he was a senior executive with Bruck Mills and I worked at Hancock Woodward & Neill, the accounting firm that provided secretarial services to Bruck.

 

Arnold’s retirement, and separation by geography, has meant that I’ve had no contact with Arnold for many years; but I do trust that his final years were good ones.

 

 

To a former workmate on the death of his wife:

 

I knew that your office was in Swan Hill, but it wasn’t until Cup Day last year – when I was in Swan Hill - that I came upon it by chance.  I was with a cousin, and told the story of how we’d been in the same office when you came to Melbourne to work many years ago.

 

My cousin remembered your name, and when recently thumbing through some old papers saw your wife’s death notices and passed them on to me.  Ironically, I was rediscovering your whereabouts on the very day that she died.

 

Richard it was obviously a very tragic occurrence, and I send my sincere sympathy.  I trust that the intervening weeks have brought you some consolation and that - so far as is possible – things are returning to “normal”.

 

 

To a workmate on the death of his brother:  

 

Quite apart from the personal loss and suffering there is always something tragic about an upturning of the natural order of things. Parents should not bury their children; and young men should not die.  It is against this backdrop that I extend my very sincere sympathy to you and your family, and especially to your parents.

 

With a senseless death there is no immediate consolation, and only time can heal; but it may be of some comfort to know that there are others - like myself – who in some small way are sharing your grief with you.

 

 

To the family of a long-ago business associate: 

 

I’m writing to express my sorrow at the death of Howden Selleck.  Howden and I worked together on mutual client matters back in the early 1960s, first when I was with the accounting firm of Hancock Woodward & Neill and later when I was a partner with the firm of Irish Young & Outhwaite.  Working with him was a great pleasure.

 

Over the years we have “bumped into each other” from time to time and renewed our acquaintance; but I regret that in later years professional life has taken me to the suburbs, and that Howden had become a friend of my past rather than the present.

 

 

To the family of a client:  

 

I read your mother’s death notice with some sadness, and am writing to express my sympathy.

 

The connection, although a professional one, goes back a long way (including the connection with your father) and, in reality, was more in the nature of a friendship.

 

That’s the way I feel; and I’m sorry that Sue has died.

 

 

To the family of a friend and former work colleague:

 

I was saddened (and disbelieving) to read of Ron’s death, in the latest issue of the chartered accountants’ magazine.

 

Ron and I were together for a time at Deloitte in the 1980s, but I had known him as a leading accountant and tax academic for many years prior.  Perhaps you have an incomplete idea of how significant a contribution Ron made to the field of tax practice in Australia – let me tell you, it was nonpareil.

 

With me located in Melbourne and Ron in Sydney our opportunities for fellowship were few but, at conferences and other such, Ron and I developed a close friendship – much more than work or professional colleagues.

 

After we respectively left Deloitte I made it a point of meeting with Ron every time I was in Sydney.  We habitually met for breakfast at Circular Quay, with me arriving from my hotel, and Ron coming across the harbour by ferry.  And on occasion I was Ron’s guest at his beloved “tax lunches”.

 

Our most recent meeting was in March of this year when I was passing through Sydney on the way north, when my wife and I met with Ron for breakfast at the Queen Victoria building.  Ron was as alert and lively as ever, and we passed a happy couple of hours.

 

I am so sad at his passing, and you have my sincerest condolence.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate and business partner:

 

I write to offer my condolences at this time of your grief.

 

The grief will pass, but there will always be loving memories of Rob.  He was a fine man, one who was a pleasure to work with and a pleasure to know.

 

Best wishes.

 

 

To the widower of a cousin:

 

While Ellie’s interment at Cheltenham was not a happy occasion Anne and I were pleased to attend, to lend our comfort.  We offer again our sincere condolences.  Ellie was someone special in our lives, someone who was always a pleasure to see; someone who, despite her health problems, was always cheery and always coping.

 

We hope that the pain of the past ten days will soon pass, and that you will be sustained by your loving memories, and by the support of those around you.

 

Anne joins with me in sending our best wishes.

 

 

To a former work colleague on the death of his wife:  

 

I’m writing to offer my sincere sympathy on the death of Joan.  I saw the funeral report in the paper but it wasn’t until this week that I was able to contact Peter Manuel and confirm that it was indeed the Joan McLaughlan I once knew.

 

Peter tells me that Joan had a protracted illness, and while this has its own horrible aspects I guess it does prepare you for the inevitable.  I trust that you are coping well and that things for you will soon return to a reasonably normal state.  I’m sure that, at this time, you’re getting much comfort from your family.

 

My days at Hancock Woodward & Neill seem such a long time ago, and yet my mind often wanders back to those very happy (and less complicated) days.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate:  

 

Tony Gregory has passed on the sad news of Ian’s death.  I extend my condolence, and best wishes, to you and your family.

 

I guess that, at this stage, you are relieved that Ian’s trials are over, and the full realization of your loss has yet to hit you. When it does, please be comforted by the knowledge that Ian's many friends are mourning with you.   He was a good man.

 

 

To the widow of a business associate:

 

How sad for you!

 

It is hard to comprehend Matt’s death, because he was a man of such vitality, and good humour.

 

I have known and, on occasions, worked with him for over 40 years, first in my days as an Irish Young & Outhwaite tax partner, then at Deloitte, and later when we were both Trustees of Australian Landscape Trust. 

 

Matt was a thoroughly solid professional, and a delight to be with and be associated with.  You are proud of his achievements, no doubt, and – take it from one who’s watched and admired – rightly so.

 

More important, though, was Matt the man: the husband, father and grandfather.  Your family’s tribute in the bereavement columns leaves no doubt as to where Matt did his best work.

 

I offer my sincere condolence to you and your family.

 

 

To the widow of a former business partner:  

 

Well Roy had a marvellous send-off!  A beautifully prepared and delivered tribute from G.R., and totally appropriate words of comfort from S.K.; and such a lovely gathering of friends, associates and colleagues.  And, of course, Roy’s grieving family.

 

To you and your family: please accept sincere condolences from Anne and myself.

 

I don’t think the actual expression was used on Thursday, but the truth is that Roy was a good man.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate:

 

I attended John’s memorial service last Friday and was quite overwhelmed by the heartfelt tributes.  John was clearly a loving and much loved man; and I am writing to add my personal condolence.

 

While John and I have seen little of each other over the years, our association “goes back a long way”.  My recollection is that after leaving university John went into teaching, while I went straight into the accounting profession, joining Hancock & Woodward (later Hancock Woodward & Neill).   I claim credit for having introduced John to that firm – in the sense that I saw him and chatted with him in the foyer as he was waiting for his initial interview.  I left Hancocks in 1972 and my connection with John was thereafter sporadic – although interestingly it was John who, as a representative of the Institute of Chartered Accountants, conducted the quality review audit of my present firm about three years back.  It was soon after that I learned of John’s departure from the profession and his plan for a major change of direction.  Sadly it was not to be.

 

The family was no doubt comforted by the large attendance last Friday and by the range of people whose lives John had touched.

 

 

To a long-time interstate client and friend on the death of his partner:  

 

Annie and I have been home since Friday, and the mail has been sorted and actioned.  Our renovated kitchen area is splendid, and the cupboards have been re-charged – and we can again see the floors in the other rooms.  We’re still awaiting the electrician and the painter for the final bits, but it’s looking good.

 

It was really pleasant to catch up with you – after quite a number of years – and to see that you’d lost none of your humorous demeanour, and are “wearing well”.  I was sorry, though, to learn of Lorna’s death.  You know I never met or knew her, but I was aware of her as a long-time presence in your life.  I could see, on Wednesday, that the loss is still a raw wound.  You have my sincerest sympathy.

 

 

To a long-time workmate and friend on the death of her husband:  

 

I’m so sorry to learn of Eugene’s death.  I know that he had poor heath over the years, but this doesn’t make his sudden death any easier to bear.  And what a shame that you and Sandy weren’t at his bedside when the end came.

 

And I’m sorry to learn that you are having so much difficulty in coping with your loss.  I remember giving the eulogy for a beloved uncle, and I said something like he had merely lost his life, but we – the mourners – had lost him!  Sounds harsh, but it’s so true.  Still, the void in your life is filled with memories, and that’s a great compensation……..so long as you are able, while using those memories for sustenance, to live in the present.  They call it “moving on”.

 

Best wishes to you and Sandy.  Anne sends her regards.

 

 

To the widow of a former client:

 

I was saddened to see the newspaper report of Martin’s death.  I knew Martin quite well some thirty years ago when I worked with the accounting form, Hancock & Woodward, and prepared Martin's tax returns.  Although our professional contact ceased long ago, we have maintained a friendly acquaintanceship over the years.  Each time I ran into Martin he treated me as an old friend, as indeed I was.

 

My sincere sympathy to you and the family.

 

 

To the widower of a friend in the country:

 

You could hardly say that we saw a lot of Nyree, and you could hardly call us close friends, but Nyree was a friend nonetheless, and her death really shocked and affected us.  The turn-out at her funeral was a clear indication of how widely she was loved and respected.

 

You have our deepest sympathy.

 

 

To the children of a former employer on the death of his widow:

 

You won’t remember me, but I used to work with your dad at Hancock Woodward & Neill.  During those years your folks were very involved with staff and I recall many social get-togethers at your home.

 

All this came back to mind when I read the report of your mother’s death.  Please accept my sincere sympathy.

 

 

To an interstate bookseller and friend:  

 

The opportunity is not presented to many of us to pen an obituary for one we love.

 

Tragically, you have been given that distinction: your moving tribute to Maureen quite affected me.

 

I have no doubt that you will carry on – you have your business, the support of your daughter, Tara……….and your memories.  

 

And the best wishes of your network of friends and customers, including me.

 

 

To a former workmate on the death of his father:

 

This is a voice from the past, triggered by the newspaper notice of your father’s death.  Please accept my condolence.

 

I am prompted to write by the fact that our paths are unlikely to cross otherwise.  The last time we had a chat you were, I think, working with the uniform suppliers in Bourke Street.  I’m not sure that I knew your domestic situation.

 

I had moved on from Hancocks, and was with Irish Young & Outhwaite, later to merge with Deloitte.  My latest move, having been a partner for some sixteen years, has been to set up a “two man band” accounting practice with another Deloitte man, and we’re to be found in downtown Ringwood.  On the home front: wife and three pretty-grown-up kids, 23, 21 and 16. Time has flown!

 

Please give me a call.  I would enjoy catching up, and chatting about old times.

 

 

To the widow of a former workmate:

 

A note to express my sorrow at Ian’s death.  I was a long-time workmate of Ian’s at Deloitte, and proud to call him “friend”.  Ian had a difficult and demanding job, and life had not dealt him a full hand, but he remained ever cheerful and always cooperative, and it was a privilege to have known him.

 

 

To the children of a friend and former neighbour:

 

This is a note in belated formal acknowledgement of Tom’s death, and to express our condolences.

 

I was able to attend the thanksgiving Mass on 7 December, and was most impressed at the number of people who attended.  When someone lives to such a grand age there are few remaining friends, and you expect a small gathering; so the large number was a tribute to the extent of Tom’s acquaintanceships and influence, and the respect in which he was held. 

 

As you very rightly pointed out, he was not an easy man – the words irascible, indeed ornery, come to mind – but he was also my most unforgettable character.  He had the most Wagnerian way of ringing a doorbell – indeed our first encounter, after moving into number 26 Summerhill Road, was Tom announcing at our front door: “G’day.  I’m Tom Baker from across the road.  I’m an alcoholic!”  Typically blunt; typically no nonsense; and typically commandeering the conversation. When asked to explain, Tom said that he hoped to be a guest in our home, and wanted us to understand from the outset that we must never serve him alcohol.  

 

He was certainly a reformed drinker……..and had countless stories of former workmate “drunks” who were now pushing up daisies. His tales were endless, and his way of telling them was unique.  Invariably, the niceties of greeting were by-passed, and Tom would launch straight into some story – often from the other side of Denman Avenue as he came charging across.

 

Not surprisingly, Tom’s take on gambling was outspoken.  It is a vice far worse than the grog.  When you drink to excess you get so drunk that you fall into the gutter and can drink no more; but with gambling, you gamble all that you have, and then what you can borrow, and then what you can steal – you never stop. 

 

Final reminiscence:  Tom was a good hater of politicians and officials, and he expressed his contempt with gusto, indeed venom.  Can’t you see and hear him say:  “Those bastards!”  Literally frothing at the mouth, with the words growling from deep down his throat. 

 

The world has lost a man of passion; and if he wasn’t always right he was wrong in the best possible way.

 

Annie joins with me in sending best wishes.

 


To the widow of a former business partner:

 

Ian was a great mentor to me, and central to my professional life for more than a decade (he was the reason I sought employment at Irish Young), and it is hard to imagine him not being around.  Please accept my sincere sympathy.

 

Now the hard part begins, when you have to adapt to being without Ian, and to being physically alone.  But you are not really alone – you have family and friends……..and memories.  The memorial service, I’m sure, must have been a great consolation, and will be something to look back on with pleasure and pride.

 

Do please call me if you need help with tax returns, etc.

 

The subject of this letter of condolence, Ian Sutcliffe, has the distinction of being one of the few whose full name appears in this blog.  Here is the obituary I wrote for a taxation profession publication, preceded by an editorial introduction:

 

"Gary Andrews was a partner of Ian during Ian's later professional years. Gary particularly remembers Ian at Institute professional development courses in the 1970s where Ian's answers to public forum questions were invariably 'just right'.  Gary attributes this to Ian's wide experience, his almost total recall of past events, and his common sense approach.

 

Ian Terres Sutcliffe

 

9 February 1927 - 6 September 1994 

 

Ian Sutcliffe might be described as one of the last of the old school of tax accountants - those apprenticed through the accounting profession, and gaining general grounding before coming to tax as a specialisation.  He was long-time senior tax partner in the Melbourne office of Young & Outhwaite, later Irish Young & Outhwaite, and later again Deloitte Haskins & Sells.  He retired from that firm in 1985.

 

Ian's origins were in Essendon, and he retained a life-long loyalty and affinity with that suburb and the Australian rules team that bears its name. He did this despite having spent most of his life living in Blackburn and working in the city.

 

Ian Sutcliffe had a wide range of interests, including a love for the Savage Club (where he was for some years treasurer), and lively participation in sub-district cricket.  He played competitively for more than 40 years as opening batsman, and occasional slow left-arm bowler, retiring from the pitch at the age of 55.

 

As a tax practitioner, and as a man, Ian Sutcliffe feared no man and no thing, and his tireless pursuit of the 'right answer' was legend among his workmates. He literally worried problems to death. He regarded tax officials as opponents, but never enemies, and this made him a fine advocate for his clients.  In the days when the system was less stitched up by Rulings, he was able to negotiate successfully with senior tax people. In this regard he maintained a high profile in the tax profession, serving on various liaison committees, and was well known and respected by high-ranking tax officials in Melbourne and in Canberra.

 

Ian was a member of this Institute for some 25 years and, typically, was not content to play only a passive role.  He served on State Council for an impressive 14 years, and was State Chairman in 1978 and 1979.  He was the sleeves-rolled-up chairman of the organising committee for the Institute's National Convention held in Melbourne in 1983.

 

Ian died of cancer, having fought his last fight with fortitude.  The large attendance at his memorial gathering was manifest indication of the many lives he had touched.  He leaves his widow Margaret, two adult children, two grandchildren, his friends, and many former colleagues who remember him with admiration and affection."

 

Gary Andrews